Best Toilets to Buy – Buying Guide

As modern technology evolves, consumers expect the newest phones, TVs, cars and more to constantly come out with new features that make life that much more convenient.

And this evolution doesn’t just apply to electronics! When it comes to toilets, many people think there is only one type – the good old fashioned porcelain toilet that we’re all familiar with. But that actually couldn’t be farther from the truth!

There are many types of toilets that are modern and high-functioning, which include advanced features. From high efficiency toilets to water-saving technology to the modern super flush toilet, answering the question of how to choose a toilet requires more though than it used to.

Whether you’re remodeling your bathroom or just looking to replace the current toilet in your home (or maybe you’re just looking for a more comfortable toilet seat) this in depth buying guide can help you find the best toilets to buy that match your needs and your budget.

So what is the best toilet to buy? Let’s take a closer look.

When you’re thinking about purchasing a toilet, you’ll want to ask yourself whether a pressure assisted toilet or a gravity feed toilet is best for your needs. The best toilet to buy usually falls into one of these two categories, though statistically, more people tend to go with the gravity feed model.

So what’s the difference between these two toilets?

A pressure assist toilet, also known as a pressure-flush toilet, uses compressed air, or a small water pump to generate its flushing power.

Best Toilet to Buy

Photo courtesy of

There are several pros to consider if you invest in a pressure assist toilet, which include:

  • Experiencing fewer toilet clogs over time
  • Enjoying the fact that your toilet will be cleaner on a regular basis
  • Using 1.1 to 1.4 fewer gallons per flush, saving water
  • They can flush almost anything
  • Saving money on monthly water bills with one of these high efficiency toilets

Cons of Pressure Assisted Toilets

On the other hand, there are also a few cons to consider when you’re wondering if this is the best toilet to buy:

  • Pressure assisted toilets can be quite noisy every time you flush them
  • If it needs repair, the parts a pressure assisted toilet requires to function aren’t always easy to find in most hardware stores
  • Over time, the pressure can negatively affect older pipes, which can sometimes experience holes or leaks
  • These toilets can cost up to $700

Price range for pressure assisted toilets – $200 to $700

Pros of Gravity Feed Toilets

Now let’s take a look at the other model to consider when answering the question of how to choose a toilet – the gravity feed toilet.

A gravity feed toilet is what is sounds like; it uses gravity to operate. To move water down the drain, water simply drops from the toilet’s tank down into the bowl, which doesn’t use as much water pressure.

Here are the benefits of purchasing and using a gravity feed toilet:

  • These toilets flush much more quietly than a pressure assisted toilet
  • If the water flows a bit higher, an overflow tube will prevent spilling outside the tank
  • They are simple when it comes to daily operation; this model has been around for decades because it is so effective and doesn’t often break down
  • They’re easy to fix if something does happen to go wrong

Cons of Gravity Feed Toilets

Now that we’ve reviewed a few of the benefits, let’s take a look at the cons to consider with gravity feed toilets:

  • The flush mechanism can sometimes act up, requiring repair
  • The hoses sometimes leak, which calls for repair as well
  • If you use a lot of toilet paper, there isn’t a lot of pressure to ensure it is properly flushed and moved through the drain

Price range for gravity feed toilets – $100 to $600

As with any type of purchase, the pros are good for sure and not so good for others, while the cons may or may not be a factor for your particular needs. It’s wise to take a look at these pros and cons and then decide what is important to you when you ask yourself what is the best toilet to buy.

Features Section

When you’re looking for the best toilets to buy, you also want to be conscious of more than just pressure assist versus gravity feed; it’s a good idea to take an in depth look at the specific features that toilet model offers.
Here are some of the important features to consider:

Flush mechanism – keep in mind that nowadays, plastic flush towers are common, as they last longer over time (rubber flaps aren’t commonly used anymore).

Water supply lines – if your water supply lines are made of chrome-plated copper, you may want to consider replacing them with stainless steel. Furthermore, investing in a water shut-off valve is a good idea.

WaterSense certification – it’s also a good idea to invest in WaterSense certification, which means that specific toilet model uses 1.28 gallons or less per flush (compared to 1.6 gallons). This means the toilet is highly efficient and more water environmentally conscious.

Dual-flush technology – when toilets incorporate dual-flush technology, this means you push a button like the one shown in the image below. One button is designed for liquid waste and one button is designed for solid waste (a more full flush).

high efficiency toilets - BFP Bay Area

Photo courtesy of

Touchless flushing – if you’re especially germ conscious, touchless flushing is a great feature to consider. Toilets with this built in use a sensor and allow you to simply wave your hand to begin a flush. Sometimes it comes built into toilets, while sometimes you can buy a separate kit to install on an existing toilet (though this only works with certain models).

Touchless flushing - BFP Bay Area

Photo courtesy of

Bowl shape – consider whether you want a round vs elongated toilet bowl shape (elongated bowls take up more space than round bowls). The benefit of an elongated bowl shape is that some people find that it’s more comfortable to sit on. Think about what standard toilet size works best for your bathroom.

Flush valve – to ensure that water is transferred from the tank into the bowl, gravity flow toilets utilize a flush valve. The thicker the valve, the more pressure it puts out when transferring the water.

Flush Valve - BFP Bay Area

Image courtesy of

Two-piece design – most of the toilets on the market utilize a two-piece design, which is less expensive than a one-piece design; this means the tank is separate from the actual toilet bowl. Keep in mind that two-piece design toilets are harder to clean, as the seam between the pieces can collect dirt and grime over time.

Rough-in dimensions – be sure to take measurements before you shop for a toilet. The rough-in dimensions signify the distance between the back wall to connect to the water line.

Rough-in dimensions - BFP Bay Area

Noise level – depending on where your bathroom is located, the noise the flush makes is important to consider. If your bathroom is near your kitchen or a gathering area, you may want to invest in a quieter gravity feed toilet to minimize noise.

Color – though the most commonly purchased toilet color is white, there are other colors available.

Bowl height – a comfort height toilet is 17 to 19 inches high, which is the approved handicap toilet height (when compared to lower-to-the-ground toilets, which are normally 14 to 15 inches high).

Concealed or skirted trapways – the visible bends on the backside of the toilet are called trapways. If the trapways are concealed, they have a smooth surface, whereas skirted trapways show a clean line from the front to the back of the toilet.

Hopefully this guide will help you approach the question of how to buy a toilet when you need assistance!